Diden All articles
Opinion

Somebody Has to Say Something About the Coleslaw

Diden
Somebody Has to Say Something About the Coleslaw

Photo: Unknown, CC BY 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The review begins: “The bread was fine. I want to be clear about that.”

It is 1,100 words long. It is about a sandwich shop in Ohio. By paragraph four, the writer has established a timeline, quoted a server's exact phrasing, described the ambient music as “aggressive in a way I couldn't name at the time but can now: it was confident,” and introduced a second act involving a parking lot.

I have read this review four times. It is, structurally, better than most things I have read this year.

A Genre Nobody Assigned

Nobody invented the one-star review. It accumulated. Early review culture was utilitarian — a phone number for a plumber, a warning about a transmission shop. Then the star average became a business's lifeline, the review box became the default text field for complaint, and somewhere in there millions of people who have never once described themselves as writers started writing essays for strangers.

That's the definition of folk art, more or less: made by people who were not asked, for an audience that shares their context, according to rules nobody wrote down. Quilts. Mix tapes. The one-star review of a brunch place in Tempe that opens with “I am not a difficult person, but.”

Close Reading: The Sandwich

What makes the best of these reviews work isn't rage. Rage is cheap and it's boring by paragraph two. It's the specificity. The unhinged review is almost always a documentary.

Consider the recurring move of establishing provenance: “We arrived at 11:52. I know because I looked at my phone when we sat down, and I looked again at 12:41, which is when the food came.” The timestamp is not evidence. The timestamp is dramatic structure. It's the same reason a good essay tells you what year it is.

Or the reveal, which these writers land with genuine comic timing: “I ordered the turkey club. I received a philosophy.” Or the escalation into the abstract, where a complaint about coleslaw becomes a meditation on the decline of a town, and you can feel the writer discovering mid-sentence that this is what they actually wanted to talk about.

The injury is almost never the food. Read enough of these and the pattern is unmistakable. The grievance is being unconsidered — the feeling of having been processed rather than served. Someone forgot them. Someone was having a day and it got on them. The review is the receipt for that feeling.

The Parking Lot Always Has a Monologue

The parking lot is the most reliable character in the genre. It gets more stage time than the owner. So does the music volume, the sticky table, the server who “seemed annoyed,” the bathroom door that didn't latch. These aren't details. They're set dressing in a moral universe the reviewer is building at 11 p.m. on a laptop.

And here's the thing that separates the good ones from the merely angry: the good ones give the other side a little oxygen. A line like “She may have been new. I've been new.” One sentence of mercy, dropped in the middle of a demolition, is what makes a review feel like it was written by a person instead of a mood.

The Review Is Not for the Restaurant

Almost nobody writing a 900-word one-star review believes the owner is the audience. The audience is other customers — and, increasingly, the writer themselves. The review is a public diary entry with a venue attached, and the venue matters. You can't post this on your own feed. It would be weird. On a review site, it's a contribution.

The uncomfortable part: it's also a lever. A three-star average can reshape a small restaurant's year. This is a real amount of power for someone who is, by their own admission, mostly upset about how they felt at 12:41. Both things are true at once. The genre is artful, democratic, occasionally beautiful, and it can also be a week of somebody's rent.

Main Street, Reviewed

What the reviews reveal about American Main Street is that we still want to be known, and we've lost most of the places to do it. There's no manager to write a letter to. The 800 number routes to a script. You can't leave a review for the zoning board or the property manager or the guy who decided the crosswalk could wait. So you review the burrito place, and you put everything in it.

And the genre does real civic work it never gets credit for. Reviewers function as an unpaid inspection corps: the broken step, the fridge door that doesn't close, the case of bad oysters flagged at 8 a.m. on a Sunday. The same instinct that produces a 1,100-word sandwich essay also produces the review that keeps someone from getting food poisoning. Folk art has a utility belt.

Five Stars for the Ranting

So here's my defense of this stuff, offered without irony, from a person whose favorite literary form is currently gated behind a login and a “post” button.

The one-star review is one of the last places in American life where a normal person will voluntarily write eight hundred words. No prompt. No editor. No algorithm rewarding a specific length. Just a person with a grudge, a keyboard, and an instinct that this should be set down somewhere it can be read.

It's unfair. It's disproportionate. The coleslaw did not deserve a paragraph about the death of civic life. But the impulse — I was here, I noticed, somebody has to say something — is the impulse behind every good thing anyone has ever written on the internet.

Read them like literature. Read them like mail from a stranger who is having a year. And tip the server, who is very likely also writing something in Notes.

All Articles

Related Articles

The Typo Is a Love Language, and AI Is About to Correct It Out of Existence

The Typo Is a Love Language, and AI Is About to Correct It Out of Existence

The Highlight Reel Doesn't Remember Your Tuesdays

The Highlight Reel Doesn't Remember Your Tuesdays

Everybody Knows Your Username: The Digital Town Squares Nobody's Monetizing

Everybody Knows Your Username: The Digital Town Squares Nobody's Monetizing